ACCC Eyes Social Media Influencers & Dodgy Reviews
The ACCC has provided an update on the next steps in its ongoing work to scrutinise misleading online reviews and influencer endorsements.
Two short reports, outline details of the findings of the ACCC’s recent internet sweeps of social media influencers and online reviews.
“The next steps in our continuing scrutiny of these important parts of the online economy include developing strong guidelines for online operators so they clearly know what we expect, before a renewed focus on enforcement,” ACCC acting chair Catriona Lowe (lead image) said.
“Influencers and businesses need to review their practices and improve compliance with the Australian Consumer Law to ensure consumers can trust the information they find online.”
Of the 118 social media influencers reviewed in the ACCC’s influencer sweep, 81 per cent were found to be making posts that raised concerns under the Australian Consumer Law for potentially misleading advertising.
The sweep reviewed influencers across seven sectors, with most influencers in each sector making concerning posts. This ranged from 96 per cent of fashion influencers reviewed making concerning posts to 73 per cent of gaming and technology influencer posts raising concern.
“Influencers often cultivate an image of themselves as being relatable and genuine, which can create an element of trust with their followers when it comes to recommendations,” Lowe said.
“Based on the findings of our sweep, we are concerned that influencers, brands and advertisers are taking advantage of consumers’ trust through hidden advertising in social media posts by influencers.”
The sweep reviewed influencers on Instagram, TikTok, Snapchat, YouTube, Facebook, and the livestreaming service, Twitch. These influencers were tipped off to the ACCC from consumers.
The majority of influencers reviewed had large followings, however the sweep included some influencers with smaller followings.
The most common issue identified in the sweep was influencers not disclosing brand relationships in their posts.
“Many of the influencers we reviewed did not make adequate disclosures in their posts where it appeared they were receiving payment, gifts or other incentives to promote brands, products or services,” Ms Lowe said.
Another common issue was influencers using vague or confusing language to disclose advertising, such as ‘sp’ and ‘spon’ instead of ‘sponsored’.
“We found that many influencers were formatting their posts to hide their advertising disclosure or make it difficult for consumers to notice it.”
“Under the Australian Consumer Law, businesses must not mislead or deceive consumers. This applies to influencers engaging in trade or commerce, as well as brands and marketers using influencers to advertise online.”
“Influencers and brands may break the law if they do not take reasonable steps to ensure consumers are not misled to believe that sponsored posts are genuine.”
The ACCC will release guidance in early 2024 for influencers and businesses to remind them of their obligations under the Australian Consumer Law to disclose advertising in social media posts.
“The influencer industry is complex and constantly evolving, with many parties involved that may not be fully aware of good practice. We will engage with the industry on our upcoming guidance to ensure they are informed of their obligations and have no excuses for failing to make adequate disclosures.”
Influencers are reminded that they should:
- Ensure they clearly disclose a promotional post in a way that is immediately obvious to consumers. This includes instances where the influencer has received free products, tickets or any other gifts or incentives.
- Never make misleading claims about a product. This means that influencers cannot misrepresent their experience with a product.
- Not use manipulative or deceptive advertising practices.
Similarly, businesses should:
- Ensure influencers are aware of their Australian Consumer Law obligations when promoting their products or services.
- Be careful when providing influencers with scripts to follow when making posts. Scripts should never require influencers to misrepresent their experience or views on a product.
“The ACCC will continue to monitor influencers and businesses and where we see continued non-compliance we may take enforcement action,” Lowe said.
BUSINESSES FOUND TO BE MANIPULATING ONLINE REVIEWS
In a separate internet sweep to identify fake or misleading online reviews, the ACCC found that 37 per cent of the 137 businesses reviewed had engaged in concerning conduct.
“Our sweep indicates that some businesses are manipulating online reviews to present a more favourable impression of their business to consumers,” Ms Lowe said.
“Misleading reviews cause considerable harm to consumers who increasingly seek out and rely on online reviews to help them make a purchase.”
The sectors with the highest proportions of potentially fake or misleading online reviews were household appliances and electronics, beauty products, and home improvement and household products and services. Those with the lowest proportion of potentially fake or misleading online reviews were health products, and food and restaurants.
The sweep found a prevalence of businesses using third-party professional reviewers and review removalists as a tool to manage their online reputation. The ACCC reviewed 24 of these businesses that offer services to create fake reviews, remove negative reviews and prevent or edit negative reviews.
The sweep found that some third-party review management services enable review manipulation by encouraging businesses to choose which reviews to publicly display. This includes directing customers with positive experiences to post a public review, while referring those with negative experiences directly to the business.
“Businesses that seek to create fake reviews or edit or remove genuine negative reviews, with the intention of inflating their own ratings, lowering their competitors’ ratings, or hiding genuine negative reviews from the public, are in breach of the Australian Consumer Law,” Ms Lowe said.
“Whilst it may be important to businesses to manage their online reputation, they need to ensure that in doing so they are not misleading consumers.”
“The ACCC will continue to monitor businesses that offer services to facilitate the manipulation of consumer reviews, including the removal, blocking or prevention of legitimate consumer reviews about a product, service or business.”
The sweep also found that most businesses and third-party review platforms were not disclosing whether reviews were incentivised and did not require reviewers to disclose whether they had received a benefit or incentive for submitting a review.
“Businesses that do not disclose incentivised reviews are likely to mislead consumers as it presents incentivised reviews as impartial when they are not,” Ms Lowe said.
“Many businesses reviewed also appear to have fake positive reviews on their website or third-party review platforms, which is in contravention of the law.”
Some signs for consumers that positive reviews may be fake include:
- a spike in highly positive reviews about the business over a short period of time
- multiple reviews written by the same reviewer
- generic reviews without individualised or specific detail about the business or product
- reviews written in similar language as other reviews for the same business or product
- reviews on the business’ website being overwhelmingly positive while on third-party platforms there’s a mix of reviews for the business
- “The findings of our online reviews sweep will inform our education, compliance and enforcement activities with businesses, including producing updated guidance material for businesses and review platforms.”
“We will also develop educational material for consumers to help them identify potentially fake or misleading online reviews,” Lowe said.
Latest News
Fighting For ‘Attention’: How To Measure Campaigns In Today’s Content Saturated World
When it comes to ad campaigns, have you ever felt you’re ‘fighting’ for your audience’s attention? You’re not alone. Attracting and retaining audience attention in today’s digitally fragmented environment has never been more challenging. In fact, a recent study by Microsoft concluded that the human attention span has dropped to eight seconds – shrinking nearly […]
Opinion: ‘Lift While You Climb’ To Accelerate Progress & Collective Advancement
Women shouldn't pull the ladder up after them once they reach the top, argues this op-ed.
Women Paving the Path In Tech & Loyalty Share Key Insights
In the ever-evolving landscape of technology and loyalty, women are not just breaking barriers but reshaping the future. As we celebrate International Women’s Day and rally behind the theme of investing in women to accelerate progress, we made a conscious choice to forego the statistics that underscore the ongoing journey towards true gender parity. Instead, […]
Empowering Change: Women Leading The Generative AI Revolution In Marketing For International Women’s Day
The theme for this year’s International Women’s Day, “Inspire Inclusion”, establishes a poignant tone for fostering authentic change. It perfectly mirrors the dynamic landscape of marketing, where change is the only constant. The last third-party cookie has finally crumbled, privacy laws are tightening, and now, Generative AI is quickly ushering in a new era of […]
Stevie-Ann Dovico Moves From NAB To Beyond Bank
Stevie-Ann Dovico (lead image), has made the shift to customer-owned, Beyond Bank as its new chief information officer. The announcement came via Linkedin with happy to share that she is “ready to create real impact for and with our people, customers and communities” in her new role. Dovico replaces Fiona Floyd, who left the role […]
Redefining Tech Leadership: Deputy’s C-Suite Now 80% Women
Deputy, the leading global people platform for hourly work, has announced the appointment of Sejal Patel Daswani (lead image) as its new chief people officer, resulting in a shift in the composition of its senior leadership, with women now making up 80% of the company’s C-Suite. Daswani has led people functions at every stage and […]
Creativity, Advertising & Design: Bonzai’s Pooja Kulkarni Discusses Making Pathways For Equitable Change
As recent research detailing Australia’s gender gap brings stark realities to light, it’s evident, now more than ever, the need that exists to hear and celebrate the diverse perspectives of women. In this article, Pooja Kulkarni (lead image), director product & design at Bonzai shares her approach to product development – one that’s built on […]
Facebook To Abandon News Content In Australia
The news marks a big blow for news publishers in Australia. But will users actually care?
Cloudflare’s Wendy Komadina Leads The Women Leading Tech People’s Choice Vote Ahead Of Monday’s Close
Do you have more friends than Wendy? There's only one way to find out!
WLT Investigates Big Tech’s Gender Pay Gaps
Big tech catches the ire of the WGEA's gender pay gap reporting. Hardly unexpected...
Digital Ad Spending Nearly Tops $15B
The online ad market just keeps on growing.
Report: True Crime Podcast Ads Almost Criminally Lucrative
True Crime pods certainly more lucrative than any advice from self-confessed finance gurus.
DoubleVerify Launches Further Tools To Avoid Dodgy Online Ads
AI at fault for explosion of dodgy-looking websites according to DoubleVerify.
Spotify Adds Odd-Ball Fortune Telling Feature
Spotify seemingly wanting to take over your life, not just your music taste.
How Canva’s Nurturing & Supportive Culture Changed The Course Of Jill Masters’ Life
Has your employer genuinely changed your life? Or just added to the drudgery. Read enviously here.
Amazon Joins The Dow Jones Index – She’s Got The Stocks – 29th February 2024
Amazon sees success in a mixed week for the tech firms.
Wellbub Unveils ‘The Ruin I Need To Fix’ Campaign: Redefining Motherhood & Championing Maternal Mental Health
Wellbub launches timely & important campaign for mothers.
Acronis Names Cybersecurity Channel Veteran Kelly Johnson As General Manager For Australia & New Zealand
Acronis has appointed Kelly Johnson (lead image)as the new general manager for Australia and New Zealand. Johnson will lead the channel-focused business, strengthening relationships with distributors and supporting partners to meet the cybersecurity demands of modern businesses in the region. With the growing pressure on Australian businesses for cybersecurity and the drive to comply with […]
TikTok & Adobe Team Up For New AI-Powered Creative Assistant
TikTok and Adobe join forces on new AI assistant. God help our For You pages.
NVIDIA Overtakes Amazon’s Market Cap For First Time In 2 Decades – She’s Got The Stock’s 15 February
Is the market cap race a pissing contest? Perhaps. Does it show how truly nuts the tech market is? Absolutely.
X Launches New Tool For Brands To List Ads Next To “Curated” Content Creator Lists
Quite what Elon considers a "premium content creator" to be remains to be seen. But we're betting it's not good.
Airbnb Puts Recent Acquisition Of AI Firm To Use In Personalised Experiences Push
Airbnb promises to put AI to use, refuses to budge on irritating "cleaning fees."
Yahoo Releases New Market Research Tool Promising Faster & Smarter Data
Yahoo releases new market research tool. Market surprised to hear the firm's still going.
Report: Aussie Tech & Digital Salaries Jumped 35% In A Year
It's good news for the industry. Even better news for coffee shops near offices.
Democracy Manifest! Vote In The Women Leading Tech People’s Choice Award!
The People's Choice Award is your chance to herald the unheralded! Or big up your mates.
Aquent Salary Guide Reveals The Gender Pay Gap Persists In Marketing, Design & Technology Fields
Aquent has released its 2024 Australian Salary Guide for marketing, design, and technology talent. This year, it explores how marketing, design, and technology roles are expanding, deep dives into gender pay gaps, and examines the movement of salaries year-on-year—both in growth and decline. Paired with Aquent’s 2023 Talent Insights Report, the Salary Guide helps organisations […]
Tech Salaries Continue To Steady Out As Businesses Remain Cautious
The hiring market is experiencing significant change, fluctuating between a frenzied candidate-short market and a more cautious employer-driven market, according to Talent’s ‘More Than Money Salary Guide 2024’. Tech and digital salaries continue to steady out but remain strong for key skillsets such as cybersecurity and AI. The report features key salaries, roles and skills […]
Surging Job Satisfaction For Australia’s Young Tech Workers Amid Labour Market Cooling
While 2021’s big workplace trend was The Great Resignation, 2024’s big trend is likely to be ‘The Big Stay’ in Australia, concludes modern HR platform HiBob in its latest research of young Australians working in the tech sector. The combination of decreasing Australian job vacancies and a remarkable increase in job satisfaction among Australia’s young tech workers in 2023 […]
After Facebook Launched 20 Years Ago, The World Would Never Be The Same
While it might be the preserve of peculiar aunts & uncles now, Facebook was truly transformative in 2004.
Robyn Denholm & Sukhinder Singh Cassidy To Headline Forbes Australia’s 2024 Women’s Summit
It's a packed lineup for this Forbes Australia summit.
Uber Launches Phone Hotline Designed To Help Vulnerable & Elderly Riders
After killing the dial-a-cab industry in metro areas, Uber returns to save riders from itself.
Meta Launches AI Detection Feature For Images Across All Its Platforms
WLT reminds readers that AI images can be easily spotted by checking the number of digits on a subject's hand.
Snap Doubles Down On AI But Continues Haemorrhaging Money
Snap really can't seem to catch a break, now reporting six straight quarters of flat or negative growth.
Spotify Hits Bumper Revenue, Despite Slashing Workforce Last Year
With numbers this good, who cares about the thousands of staff Spotify cut late last year? We do, actually.
Website Builder Squarespace Taps Francesca Scorsese (& Famous Dad) For Super Bowl Teaser
Unlike one of Marty Scorsese's films, this ad has a mercifully short running time.
ASX 200 Reaches Record High As Alphabet & Microsoft Stocks Tumble – She’s Got The Stocks – 1st February 2024
Despite Microsoft and Google slashing jobs recently, the stock market seems to be unconvinced about their performance.